Could a midfield featuring David Ginola, Gazza, Michael Carrick and Aaron Lennon have succeeded? Well it would certainly have been exciting to watch!
That's the selection of Irish supporter Sean Murphy in our ever-popular fanzone section in hotspur magazine where readers have the chance to have their say.
"I have gone for the classic 4-4-2 formation. Two attacking full-backs are a necessity as is the presence of midfielders who will run at the opposition," says Sean.
"A versatile strike partnership is vital and I'm sure the talent on this team sheet would see us create and score a lot of goals."
That attack features Teddy Sheringham and Jermain Defoe with Stephen Carr and Christian Ziege the attacking full-backs providing the ammunition from the flanks.
Catch up with the September issue of hotspur magazine and share your views on the best Spurs team ever with fellow Spurs fans. Indeed we want your feedback on a whole host of issues.
Make sure of your copy of hotspur magazine - it's on sale now.
for full details of September's hotspur.